
The detective asks you to sit down, closes the interview room door, and starts asking questions about someone who was found dead. You came in thinking you could explain what happened, but the questions have changed, and you can tell the detectives are looking at you differently now. You start measuring every answer before you give it because you do not know what they already believe or where this conversation is headed.
The Law Office of Matthew Crockett, LLC, understands how frightening it is to realize that investigators may see you as responsible for another person’s death. We are here to help you understand where you stand and stay beside you as you face what comes next.
How Can a Homicide Defense Attorney in Portland Help You?
A homicide accusation involves more than the fact that someone died. Depending on the charge, the State may need to prove what you did, whether your actions caused the death, and what you intended or knew at the time. A lawyer can identify those required parts and test whether the evidence supports them.
What Does a Homicide Charge Mean Under Maine Law?
Homicide is the broad term for one person causing another person’s death. It is not one specific criminal charge. Maine treats murder, felony murder, and manslaughter as separate crimes. Each asks the State to prove a different story about how the death happened and what you understood at the time:
- Murder. This applies when someone intentionally causes someone’s death, knew their actions would cause death, or acted with such extreme disregard for human life that death resulted. For example, deliberately shooting someone could support an intentional-murder theory, while firing into a crowded room could support a theory based on extreme disregard for human life.
- Felony Murder. This applies when someone dies during certain serious crimes, an attempt to commit one, or the immediate escape, and the death was reasonably foreseeable. For example, if two people commit a robbery and one shoots someone while they flee, prosecutors may pursue felony murder against both participants; it doesn’t matter that one only fired the gun.
- Manslaughter. This applies when someone recognizes a serious risk and ignores it, or fails to recognize a serious risk that a reasonable person would. For example, handling a loaded gun in a dangerously careless way and causing a death could support a manslaughter charge even without an intent to kill.
For each of these, the State must prove each required part of the specific charge beyond a reasonable doubt, which means that the judge or the jury must be firmly convinced of your guilt before voting to convict in a criminal trial. If there is doubt, it must be logical and based on evidence, or on missing evidence that the State failed to provide.
Murder carries 25 years to life in prison. Felony murder and the most common forms of manslaughter are called Class A crimes in Maine and generally carry up to 30 years in prison.
How Will the State Try to Prove a Homicide Charge?
Prosecutors may combine several kinds of evidence to support their version of what happened. For example:
- Your statements can affect how prosecutors describe your intent or account of the event;
- Witness accounts can shape the timeline, even when someone saw only part of what happened;
- Digital evidence can include messages, searches, location data, photos, and videos; and
- Medical and forensic evidence can affect whether the State can connect your actions to the death.
A homicide defense lawyer in Portland can compare those pieces against one another. A witness account that conflicts with phone data, a timeline that does not fit the medical evidence, or missing evidence can change how strong the State’s theory really is.
Questioned about a death?
Know Where You Stand Before You Say More
The State may rely on statements, witnesses, and digital and forensic evidence. Contact the Law Office of Matthew Crockett, LLC, for a free consultation to see how it can be tested.
What Should You Do If Police Want to Question You?
Miranda warnings are what officers are required to read to you before questioning, which you see on TV all the time. They tell you that you have the right to remain silent, that what you say can be used against you, and that you have the right to a lawyer. If they are reading them to you, you are likely considered in custody and not free to leave. Be sure you tell them that you want to remain silent and ask for an attorney.
Before an arrest, officers may knock on your door to talk to you, see you at your place of work, or call to see if you’ll come down to the station to talk with them about a death. They will attempt to make these conversations non-threatening and casual. They are not. They are unlikely to read the Miranda warnings to you, but the same rights always apply. At these times, you should also tell them that you want to remain silent and want an attorney.
A Portland homicide lawyer can instead communicate with investigators and the prosecutor. They know what is at stake and can advise you about whether speaking serves your interests or harms you.
What Can a Defense Attorney Challenge on Your Behalf?
Your defense attorney can challenge the parts of the State’s case that do not hold up against the facts or the law. Depending on your case, that may include:
- Whether your actions caused the death. Your attorney can examine medical findings, timelines, witness accounts, and other evidence to challenge the State’s claim that your conduct caused the death.
- What the State says you intended or knew. Your attorney can challenge whether the evidence actually proves the state of mind required for murder, felony murder, or manslaughter.
- Whether the evidence tells a consistent story. Your attorney can compare witness statements with physical, digital, medical, and forensic evidence and expose conflicts or missing information.
- Whether the police obtained evidence lawfully. Your attorney can challenge statements, phone data, physical evidence, or other information when investigators violated your legal rights while obtaining it.
Your attorney can also determine whether the facts support self-defense. Maine allows deadly force in certain circumstances when you reasonably believe you need it to protect yourself or another person from unlawful deadly force. Maine limits that defense in some situations if you know you can retreat with complete safety.
Why Trust the Law Office of Matthew Crockett, LLC, as Your Homicide Defense Attorney in Portland?
Matthew Crockett has handled homicide cases from both sides of the courtroom. Before opening the Law Office of Matthew Crockett, LLC, he spent more than a decade prosecuting major felonies, including homicide. He tried dozens of contested cases to verdict before judges and juries.
He has since defended people accused of homicide and served on Maine’s screened indigent-defense panels for serious felony cases, including homicides. That combination gives his clients an attorney who understands how the State develops its most serious cases and what it takes to challenge them.
Know What Comes Next in Your Homicide Case Today
If police are investigating you or the State has charged you with homicide in Portland, speaking with a Portland homicide defense attorney can help you understand what the accusation means and what decisions may come next. Contact the Law Office of Matthew Crockett, LLC, for a free consultation.
Frequently Asked Questions
When should I contact a homicide defense attorney in Portland?
You can contact one as soon as police want to question you about a death, even before any charge. Before an arrest, officers may come to your door, your workplace, or call you in for a casual conversation. A homicide defense attorney in Portland can communicate with investigators and the prosecutor and advise whether speaking helps or harms you.
What is the difference between murder and manslaughter in Maine?
Murder involves intentionally causing death, knowing your actions would cause death, or acting with extreme disregard for human life. Manslaughter involves recognizing a serious risk and ignoring it, or failing to recognize a serious risk that a reasonable person would. Felony murder applies when someone dies during certain serious crimes and the death was reasonably foreseeable.
Do police have to read me my rights before questioning me about a death?
Officers read Miranda warnings before questioning, and if they are reading them to you, you are likely in custody and not free to leave. Before an arrest, they may not read them at all, but the same rights apply. You can tell them you want to remain silent and want an attorney.
