
When someone dies in Maine, and police start asking questions, words like homicide, murder, and manslaughter can start flying before anyone explains what they actually mean.
So, what is a homicide? Homicide broadly means one person causing another’s death. It is not a single criminal charge in Maine. Depending on what happened and the accused person’s state of mind, prosecutors may pursue murder, felony murder, or manslaughter. Those distinctions affect what the State must prove and the potential sentence.
The Law Office of Matthew Crockett, LLC can help you make sense of what you may be facing and the next steps to take.
What Separates Homicide From Murder in Maine?
The difference between homicide and murder is that homicide is the broader concept, while murder is a specific criminal offense.
Maine does not divide murder into first-degree and second-degree offenses like some states. A person may be charged with murder for intentionally or knowingly causing another person’s death. Murder can also involve conduct showing depraved indifference to human life that causes a death, or intentionally or knowingly causing another person to die by suicide through force, duress, or deception.
A straightforward homicide example might involve an allegation that someone deliberately fired a gun at another person, intending to kill. A depraved-indifference case can look different because the prosecution may focus less on a specific intent to kill and more on conduct showing extreme disregard for human life, such as a fight where one person is beaten so badly that they die.
When Can a Death Become Felony Murder?
Felony murder does not require the State to prove the same intent to kill required under one theory of murder.
Maine’s felony murder law applies when someone, acting alone or with others, commits or attempts certain serious crimes, including robbery, burglary, kidnapping, arson, gross sexual assault, escape, or murder, and a participant causes a death that was a reasonably foreseeable consequence of the crime or immediate flight afterward.
For example, if several people commit a robbery and one causes a death during the incident, others may also face felony murder allegations if statutory requirements are met. What each person did or knew, and whether the death was reasonably foreseeable, can become major issues in the defense.
Felony murder is a Class A crime.
Why Can Manslaughter Look Very Different From One Case to Another?
Manslaughter covers several forms of unlawful killing with different culpable mental states and circumstances.
A person may be charged with manslaughter for recklessly causing another person’s death or causing a death through criminal negligence. Manslaughter can also apply when someone intentionally or knowingly causes a death while under extreme anger or extreme fear brought on by a legally adequate provocation. These forms are Class A crimes.
Maine also has a narrower workplace-related form of manslaughter. A person with direct management or control over employment may commit a Class C crime if they intentionally or knowingly violate an occupational safety or health standard, causing an employee’s death that was reasonably foreseeable.
These types of homicide can arise from very different facts. The circumstances surrounding the death matter just as much as the label eventually attached to the charge.
Why Does State of Mind Change the Charge?
The accused person’s state of mind can separate murder from manslaughter and one manslaughter theory from another.
Under Maine law:
- Intentionally—causing the result was the person’s conscious objective;
- Knowingly—the person was aware the result was practically certain;
- Recklessly—consciously disregarding a risk in a way that grossly departs from reasonable conduct; and
- Criminal negligence —failing to recognize a risk when that failure grossly departs from what a reasonable and prudent person would do.
These are not minor wording differences. Maine law treats culpable mental state as part of the elements the State must prove, depending on the offense. In a real case, text messages, witness statements, surveillance footage, firearm evidence, prior conduct, and the sequence of events are especially important.
Under investigation or charged in a death?
Know What the State Has to Prove
Murder, felony murder, and manslaughter each require different proof. Contact the Law Office of Matthew Crockett, LLC, for a free consultation to go over the charge or the investigation and what it means for you.
What Penalties Can Follow a Homicide Conviction in Maine?
The potential punishment depends heavily on the charge.
A murder conviction requires a sentence of life imprisonment or a definite term of at least 25 years.
Felony murder and the main forms of manslaughter are Class A crimes. Unless another sentencing rule applies, a Class A offense carries a maximum term of 30 years. The workplace-safety form of manslaughter is Class C and generally carries a maximum of five years.
Those differences are significant. Correctly identifying the theory of homicide can affect both the evidence the defense challenges and the sentencing exposure the accused faces.
Who Investigates and Prosecutes Homicides in Maine?
Homicide investigations in Maine often involve state agencies from the start.
The Maine State Police Major Crimes Units investigate homicides throughout the state except in Portland and Bangor, where the local police departments handle homicide investigations. The Maine Attorney General’s Office directs and controls homicide investigations and prosecutes murder and non-vehicular manslaughter cases.
Investigators may also work with the State Police Crime Laboratory and the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner. Forensic evidence, witness interviews, digital records, and medical findings may develop before anyone is formally charged.
What Can a Defense Lawyer Challenge in a Homicide Case?
A homicide defense requires more than reacting to the charge on a complaint. At the Law Office of Matthew Crockett, LLC, we examine how investigators built the State’s theory and whether the evidence supports the specific offense alleged.
Depending on the case, that may include:
- Reconstructing the timeline using video, phone records, messages, location data, and witness accounts;
- Reviewing forensic findings, firearm evidence, autopsy conclusions, and medical evidence;
- Testing whether the evidence supports intent, knowledge, recklessness, or criminal negligence;
- Examining causation when another event, injury, or person may have contributed to the death; and
- Separating one person’s conduct from the actions of other participants in a felony murder investigation.
The State must prove each required element beyond a reasonable doubt. In some homicide cases, the key question may be whether the accused caused the death at all. In others, the central dispute may be what the accused intended, knew, or could have reasonably foreseen.
A Homicide Charge Requires More Than a Quick Conclusion
The Law Office of Matthew Crockett, LLC, represents clients in Portland and throughout Maine. Matthew Crockett has handled serious criminal cases from several sides of the courtroom. He is a retired Marine, former prosecutor, former special public defender, military defense attorney, and military judge, and an experienced trial lawyer in state, federal, and military courts.
That perspective matters because homicide cases are rarely as simple as the first police narrative suggests. The defense must ask what happened, what the evidence proves, what mental state can be established, whether causation is clear, and whether the charge fits the facts.
Helping you find peace through strength.
If you or someone you care about is under investigation or facing a homicide charge, contact us before assumptions become the case theory. We can examine the evidence, identify the State’s legal theory, and build the defense around what the facts support.
Legal References Used to Inform This Page
To ensure the accuracy and clarity of this page, we referenced official legal and other resources during the content development process:
- Me. Rev. Stat. tit. 17-A, § 201. Murder
- Me. Rev. Stat. tit. 17-A, § 202. Felony murder
- Me. Rev. Stat. tit. 17-A, § 203. Manslaughter
- Me. Rev. Stat. tit. 17-A, § 35. Definitions of culpable states of mind
- Me. Rev. Stat. tit. 17-A, § 1603. Imprisonment for crime of murder
- Me. Rev. Stat. tit. 17-A, § 1604. Imprisonment for crimes other than murder
- Maine State Police, Major Crimes Units
- Maine Office of the Attorney General, Homicide
- Me. Rev. Stat. tit. 17-A, § 32. Elements of crimes defined
- Me. Rev. Stat. tit. 17-A, § 33. Result as an element; causation

