
You thought you understood the situation when local police started asking questions. Then someone mentions federal investigators, and suddenly you are no longer sure whether you are dealing with the same case, a different one, or both. You go home searching for an explanation, but every answer seems to introduce another term you have never had a reason to know before now.
The Law Office of Matthew Crockett, LLC, understands how difficult it is to make decisions when you do not even know which system you are dealing with. We can help you understand where your case stands and what the road ahead may look like.
Federal vs State Crimes: What Makes the Difference?
A crime becomes a federal or state matter based on which law applies and which government has the authority to prosecute the alleged conduct. Maine prosecutes violations of state law, while the federal government prosecutes violations of federal law. Some conduct can violate both.
What Is a Federal Crime?
A federal crime is conduct prohibited by federal law. Some federal laws apply because the alleged conduct involves interstate activity, federal property, a federal agency, or another area Congress has authority to regulate. Other federal statutes specifically prohibit certain conduct.
Federal criminal cases can involve allegations such as:
- Drug trafficking under federal law;
- Mail, wire, bank, or tax fraud;
- Certain firearms offenses;
- Crimes against the federal government; and
- Certain civil rights or interstate offenses.
Those are only examples. The facts and the specific statute determine whether federal law applies.
What Makes a Crime a State Crime in Maine?
Maine law enforcement and criminal courts handle alleged violations of Maine law. A district attorney’s office prosecutes most state criminal cases and can include charges such as OUI, assault, theft, domestic violence offenses, burglary, and many drug offenses.
The fact that local police started an investigation does not necessarily mean it will remain only a state matter. State, local, and federal agencies often work together, and federal prosecutors can receive cases that began with state or local investigators.
Federal Charges vs State Charges: What Changes for You?
The two systems share the same basic purpose of resolving criminal accusations, but they operate under different laws and procedural rules.
If your case moves into federal court, several things may change:
- The United States Attorney’s Office prosecutes the federal case instead of a Maine state prosecutor,
- Federal agencies likely take part in the investigation,
- Federal criminal procedure controls how the case moves through the court, and
- Federal sentencing law and guidelines may be considered in the sentencing analysis if a conviction is entered.
These differences can affect the deadlines you face, the information available to us, the decisions you need to make, and how we prepare the case.
Can the Same Conduct Lead to Both Federal and State Charges?
Yes. The same alleged conduct can sometimes violate both Maine and federal law. Federal and state prosecutors are separate branches of government, and each can have legal authority over its own offenses.
The U.S. Supreme Court has upheld this principle, known as dual sovereignty. That means a federal case does not automatically supersede a state case, and a state case does not necessarily preclude federal charges arising from the same underlying conduct.
This does not mean both governments prosecute every overlapping case; it is only how the system can work, and sometimes does.
Are Federal Charges Worse Than State Charges?
Not automatically. Some federal crimes carry severe penalties, including mandatory minimum sentences in certain cases. But Maine also prosecutes serious offenses that can result in years or decades in prison.
Federal sentencing also works differently. Federal judges calculate an advisory guideline range based on factors that can include the offense and criminal history, then consider other federal sentencing factors before imposing a sentence. The guideline range is an important part of that process, but it does not automatically dictate the final sentence.
The seriousness of your situation depends on the actual charge, the facts, your record, and the applicable sentencing laws.
Contacted by federal or state investigators?
Get the Right Lawyer Involved Early
Contact from investigators does not mean charges have been filed, but it is a reason to get advice early. Contact the Law Office of Matthew Crockett, LLC, for a free consultation to protect your rights from the start.
What If Federal Investigators Contact You Before You Are Charged?
Federal investigators can contact you while a case is still under investigation. Agencies such as the FBI, DEA, ATF, USPS, IRS Criminal Investigation, and Homeland Security Investigations may investigate suspected violations of federal law.
Contact from federal investigators does not, by itself, mean that charges have already been filed or that charges will necessarily follow. If you have been contacted, it is important to hire an attorney to protect your rights from the very beginning.
What Changes About Your Defense in Federal Court?
When we represent you, we identify which laws and rules apply, review the evidence within the correct system, explain each stage, and prepare you for the decisions ahead. A federal case may require us to evaluate different statutes, procedural rules, sentencing provisions, and investigative practices than we would in a Maine state court. If both systems are involved, we also need to understand how developments in one may affect decisions in the other.
Have the Law Office of Matthew Crockett, LLC Review Your Federal vs State Crimes
Matthew Crockett has practiced in both federal and state courts for almost 20 years, giving him firsthand experience with criminal cases across both systems. He spent more than a decade prosecuting major state felonies before becoming a defense attorney, and has practiced in military courts as a prosecutor, a defense attorney, and a judge, litigating cases to verdict before judges and juries. Few criminal defense careers span that three-jurisdiction range, and Matthew draws on that experience to help clients understand the system handling their case.
Find Out Which System You Are Dealing with Before You Make Any Decisions
If state or federal investigators have contacted you, you do not need to figure out the system by yourself before seeking help. Contact the Law Office of Matthew Crockett, LLC today for a free consultation to review the status of the case and explain what may happen next.
Legal References Used to Inform This Page
To ensure the accuracy and clarity of this page, we referenced official legal and other resources during the content development process:

